Comfort vs Dynamic - What's your take?
#11
AudiWorld Super User
All Audis with ADS have always defaulted to the D mode at start up with engine throttle and transmission gear mspping. Like it or not, It has to do with meeting Audi's stated EPA mpg ratings and requirements. A simple flick of the gear shift returns to S mode.
#12
AudiWorld Super User
I agree with the OP about S mode. 2 things I don't like/get about Dynamic mode and why I dont use it as my standard.
1: Dynamic mode I figure will auto select S mode. It never does. In dynamic the first time I select to from comfort, it will jump into S mode. but then it stays in s mode. Next time I start the car it is in D mode even though the mode is dynamic? I have tried spirited driving in dynamic but 99% of the time it stays in D mode so I figure whats the point?
2: Since it is always rev happy Dynamic mode is not smart enough to turn S mode off in traffic so it always lurches and hunts in traffic. Stays IN high gear without downshifting so it gets jerky.
I found comfort mode works best and when I want to speed, I dip into S mode from the tranny.
1: Dynamic mode I figure will auto select S mode. It never does. In dynamic the first time I select to from comfort, it will jump into S mode. but then it stays in s mode. Next time I start the car it is in D mode even though the mode is dynamic? I have tried spirited driving in dynamic but 99% of the time it stays in D mode so I figure whats the point?
2: Since it is always rev happy Dynamic mode is not smart enough to turn S mode off in traffic so it always lurches and hunts in traffic. Stays IN high gear without downshifting so it gets jerky.
I found comfort mode works best and when I want to speed, I dip into S mode from the tranny.
So normally you would have Drive Select in Auto mode for regular driving, then if you feel a bit frisky you pull back on the shifter to put the transmission in S or if you also want the steering to tighten up a bit you would select Dynamic mode. Once you got it out of your system, you revert back to Auto.
#13
AudiWorld Member
Join Date: Feb 2015
Location: Tampa,FL
Posts: 317
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I understand how it switches BUT it doesn't seem to work unless I manually engage S mode. I have driven in Dynamic and after the first time I select ADS to Dynamic, it defaults to S mode in the gear shifter.
It will stay in S mode for some period of time while driving even when I think it should totally drop back into D mode. Then while driving it will usually slip back into D mode.
Then for the next several days of driving it will never revert back into S mode it will stay in D and always feel like comfort mode.
It will stay in S mode for some period of time while driving even when I think it should totally drop back into D mode. Then while driving it will usually slip back into D mode.
Then for the next several days of driving it will never revert back into S mode it will stay in D and always feel like comfort mode.
#14
My 2 cents
#15
AudiWorld Member
Join Date: Feb 2015
Location: Tampa,FL
Posts: 317
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Yes I can see that happening too. I observe it when I let off the pedal. If cruising at 30-40mph range I am in 3rd gear and let off gas quickly. the car will engine brake and get back down to 1800rpm quickly but it won't downshift it will sit in 3rd when it should be in 2nd so it jerks then shifts.
Happens in D but not as much.
Happens in D but not as much.
#16
AudiWorld Super User
I understand how it switches BUT it doesn't seem to work unless I manually engage S mode. I have driven in Dynamic and after the first time I select ADS to Dynamic, it defaults to S mode in the gear shifter.
It will stay in S mode for some period of time while driving even when I think it should totally drop back into D mode. Then while driving it will usually slip back into D mode.
Then for the next several days of driving it will never revert back into S mode it will stay in D and always feel like comfort mode.
It will stay in S mode for some period of time while driving even when I think it should totally drop back into D mode. Then while driving it will usually slip back into D mode.
Then for the next several days of driving it will never revert back into S mode it will stay in D and always feel like comfort mode.
#17
AudiWorld Member
Join Date: Feb 2015
Location: Tampa,FL
Posts: 317
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I totally get that part S mode D mode on the tranny shift point and it defaulting to drive and how it works. My comment is about the ADS DYNAMIC SETTING IN THE MMI.
It doesnt work like I would expect. If I select DYNAMIC for first time in MMI it shifts the tranny mode INTO THE S MODE. it stays there no matter how I drive for a certain period of time and/or it will default back to D MODE from S MODE on the dash and you can feel it.
Then after that it will not select S mode again in the tranny. It will feel like comfort mode just more jerky occasionally.
It doesnt work like I would expect. If I select DYNAMIC for first time in MMI it shifts the tranny mode INTO THE S MODE. it stays there no matter how I drive for a certain period of time and/or it will default back to D MODE from S MODE on the dash and you can feel it.
Then after that it will not select S mode again in the tranny. It will feel like comfort mode just more jerky occasionally.
#18
AudiWorld Super User
I totally get that part S mode D mode on the tranny shift point and it defaulting to drive and how it works. My comment is about the ADS DYNAMIC SETTING IN THE MMI.
It doesnt work like I would expect. If I select DYNAMIC for first time in MMI it shifts the tranny mode INTO THE S MODE. it stays there no matter how I drive for a certain period of time and/or it will default back to D MODE from S MODE on the dash and you can feel it.
Then after that it will not select S mode again in the tranny. It will feel like comfort mode just more jerky occasionally.
It doesnt work like I would expect. If I select DYNAMIC for first time in MMI it shifts the tranny mode INTO THE S MODE. it stays there no matter how I drive for a certain period of time and/or it will default back to D MODE from S MODE on the dash and you can feel it.
Then after that it will not select S mode again in the tranny. It will feel like comfort mode just more jerky occasionally.
#20
AudiWorld Super User
There is no difference. D is D and S is S. What happens is that if you engage Dynamic mode, that engages S mode for the transmission. If you take the transmission out of S into D, that's the same as going into Individual mode and changing the transmission setting to Comfort or Auto, but leave everything else in Dynamic. I know Audi doesn't explain this very well in the owner's manual, but the transmission simply gives you direct control over its mode, whereas the steering mode you can only change by changing the drive select mode.