will the Audi pre sense automatically stop the car in front of a collision?
#21
Yes, otherwise I wouldn't have expected it to do anything since I don't have it. But it is just a report of one person's experience with Audi's presense plus and the S6's huge brakes and great tires, because it still couldn't stop the law of physics.
#22
Just realized I hadn't responded to the original post with my experience. My wife actually re-ended someone with my S6 while coming up on an intersection. Because she was already braking she wasn't sure if the braking guard kicked in or not. I was surprised and disappointed that the presense didn't prevent the collision but it might have mitigated it. Like others, I had 'false alarms' where it had given me a warning and even engaged when there wasn't a stopped car in my path. So with it so 'sensitive' I had a lot of confidence in it, in preventing a collision.
#23
I have experienced a number of false positives with the Audi Pre Sense that have created some frightening and dangerous situations.
Here is my understanding and research into the matter.
As described above and explained by Audi, the Pre Sense uses radar and camera information to track moving vehicles in front of your car starting at 6 MPH.
If it senses a possible collision, it gives warnings, can apply braking, closes the windows/sun roof and can also tighten the seat belts.
I have had a handful of events in the past 18 months where my 2013 S6 has braked unexpectedly when there was no obstruction in front of me.
The Use Case is very specific when this happens.
When following a vehicle that has a long body portion behind the rear wheels (think school bus with 10+ feet, long bed pickup trucks with 6 feet or airport vans with 8 feet).
When following these vehicles and the vehicles turns left or right out of the traveled path, their rear portion "swings out" on sharp turns. The radar and camera seem to register that the vehicle is coming back into a collision path, even though they are NOT in the Audi's path.
The result is anything from a chirp to a hard braking and seat belt tightening. It is pretty alarming when the car brakes hard and you clearly see that the Audi had room to continue straight without a collision.
More importantly, a vehicle following behind is not expecting a "panic stop" and I was just about rear ended the last time this happened.
The Use Case does NOT happen when you have normal cars and smaller bed trucks, which don't swing out.
My theory is that the Germans did not factor the typical American pickup trucks when they programmed the Pre Sense.
AoA understood my problem, but the CSR had no clue how to escalate it.
My dealer said they had heard about something similar and suggested that I change the settings for the Adaptive Cruise Control, but this has nothing to do with Adaptive Cruise Control.
I am at the point of wanting to write a letter to the CEO of Audi Germany asking where this issue should be escalated, as no one seems to know what to do.
Keep y'all posted...
Here is my understanding and research into the matter.
As described above and explained by Audi, the Pre Sense uses radar and camera information to track moving vehicles in front of your car starting at 6 MPH.
If it senses a possible collision, it gives warnings, can apply braking, closes the windows/sun roof and can also tighten the seat belts.
I have had a handful of events in the past 18 months where my 2013 S6 has braked unexpectedly when there was no obstruction in front of me.
The Use Case is very specific when this happens.
When following a vehicle that has a long body portion behind the rear wheels (think school bus with 10+ feet, long bed pickup trucks with 6 feet or airport vans with 8 feet).
When following these vehicles and the vehicles turns left or right out of the traveled path, their rear portion "swings out" on sharp turns. The radar and camera seem to register that the vehicle is coming back into a collision path, even though they are NOT in the Audi's path.
The result is anything from a chirp to a hard braking and seat belt tightening. It is pretty alarming when the car brakes hard and you clearly see that the Audi had room to continue straight without a collision.
More importantly, a vehicle following behind is not expecting a "panic stop" and I was just about rear ended the last time this happened.
The Use Case does NOT happen when you have normal cars and smaller bed trucks, which don't swing out.
My theory is that the Germans did not factor the typical American pickup trucks when they programmed the Pre Sense.
AoA understood my problem, but the CSR had no clue how to escalate it.
My dealer said they had heard about something similar and suggested that I change the settings for the Adaptive Cruise Control, but this has nothing to do with Adaptive Cruise Control.
I am at the point of wanting to write a letter to the CEO of Audi Germany asking where this issue should be escalated, as no one seems to know what to do.
Keep y'all posted...
#24
AudiWorld Senior Member
Audi engineers are probably working from empirical data. You know, reaction time (much quicker-than-human reflexes, in this case), expected braking distances based on closing speed, etc, etc. You're basing things on the seat of your pants. I'll leave it to you to decide which is probably more accurate
#25
AudiWorld Super User
Page 88 of my manual states "Braking Guard works within limits and will not respond outside system limits, for example when approaching a stopped vehicle or stationary obstacle." So if car ahead was stopped before the system detected it, the braking guard would not have intervened.
#26
AudiWorld Senior Member
#27
AudiWorld Super User
#28
I've had 2 incidents where Pre-sense Plus kicked in to some degree in the first 3000 miles of my A6, and here's my observations from it:
- One incident was I was trying to use ACC around a curve at 70mph, and I knew from past experience there was a high likelihood that exit lane traffic was backed up at a standstill around this blind curve. Sure enough, it was the case. The car, however, did not react until the rear of the stopped car was fully in view (while an attentive human driver would have realized seconds earlier). In this case I only got the auditory warning and I took over braking at that point, stopped in plenty of time.
- Second incident was a legitimate save. It was a long day after work and I was driving to an unfamiliar restaurant. At a highway interchange I got momentarily confused by whether I wanted East or West, and was paying more attention to the nav directions and road signs. Eventually I decided I wanted to go left, so while still looking up at the sign I pointed my car left and "BEEEEP" and felt the car jolt due to brake jabbing. Looked down and yup I had just pointed my Audi at a row of stopped cars, going 50+mph. I hit the brakes and felt the car "pull" the brake pedal from underneath me, and ended up stopping with about 5 feet to spare!
I think the latter case is one where Pre-sense Plus really saved my ***. It's one of those classic traffic mistakes that we all make from time to time, and I just happened to do it at a really bad time.
So I've noticed that the system does kick in, but does so at pretty much the last second. If I were sitting in the passenger seat watching this unfold, I would've started yelling and bracing for impact 3 seconds before Pre-Sense would've kicked in. It seems like in perfectly clear weather and ideal traction Pre-Sense Plus will bring the car to a stop in time, but most of the times it is designed to jolt you into paying attention, and mitigate the risk of a collision.
Also, note that the initial response of pre-sense plus is indeed just a sudden jab of the brakes. Not a full blown emergency stop. So a pre-sense false alarm is more of an inconvenience than a safety hazard. The manual states that if you increase accelerator input (e.g. trying to override the system intuitively), you'll disarm the pre-sense intervention.
- One incident was I was trying to use ACC around a curve at 70mph, and I knew from past experience there was a high likelihood that exit lane traffic was backed up at a standstill around this blind curve. Sure enough, it was the case. The car, however, did not react until the rear of the stopped car was fully in view (while an attentive human driver would have realized seconds earlier). In this case I only got the auditory warning and I took over braking at that point, stopped in plenty of time.
- Second incident was a legitimate save. It was a long day after work and I was driving to an unfamiliar restaurant. At a highway interchange I got momentarily confused by whether I wanted East or West, and was paying more attention to the nav directions and road signs. Eventually I decided I wanted to go left, so while still looking up at the sign I pointed my car left and "BEEEEP" and felt the car jolt due to brake jabbing. Looked down and yup I had just pointed my Audi at a row of stopped cars, going 50+mph. I hit the brakes and felt the car "pull" the brake pedal from underneath me, and ended up stopping with about 5 feet to spare!
I think the latter case is one where Pre-sense Plus really saved my ***. It's one of those classic traffic mistakes that we all make from time to time, and I just happened to do it at a really bad time.
So I've noticed that the system does kick in, but does so at pretty much the last second. If I were sitting in the passenger seat watching this unfold, I would've started yelling and bracing for impact 3 seconds before Pre-Sense would've kicked in. It seems like in perfectly clear weather and ideal traction Pre-Sense Plus will bring the car to a stop in time, but most of the times it is designed to jolt you into paying attention, and mitigate the risk of a collision.
Also, note that the initial response of pre-sense plus is indeed just a sudden jab of the brakes. Not a full blown emergency stop. So a pre-sense false alarm is more of an inconvenience than a safety hazard. The manual states that if you increase accelerator input (e.g. trying to override the system intuitively), you'll disarm the pre-sense intervention.
#29
I know you probably do not think you are tail gating too close, but I find the sensors in the Audi to be very conservative. I have seen the pre sense kick in when cars turned too slow to my anticipation and thus the car kicked in. Once thing I knew that the A6 is confirming is that I tend to follow close to cars in front of me. I have always felt comfortable with the distance and my reaction time, but obviously the A6 engineers do not agree with me.
What shocks me is that the brakes kick in when there is NO CHANCE of collision. It is not like the vehicle in front of me has stopped in the path of the Audi. It is that wide swinging motion of the rear of the vehicle in front that seems to trigger a false positive thinking the vehicle is coming back into the Audi's path.
Really not an enjoyable experience.
I live in a rural area with lots of small towns, secondary roads and long bed pick-up trucks. I imagine that city folks or highway drivers would see this less often.
#30
Pre-sense would stop car from backing up to an object?
Recently I got rear-ended by a lady after we stopped at a red light. I got out to take pictures and stuff. Then the lady said I backed up to her car!! I knew I didn't but can I mentioned this pre sense feature that would possibly explain how my car would not allow that collision? I need to win the case 100% as it was totally her fault! My Lexus would break if I say back up to a garbage container. Sure she could say I turned off the system and all that. But I plan to sue her and anything helps. Thanks