Help me understand Audi v. Subaru on winter roads
#1
AudiWorld Member
Thread Starter
Help me understand Audi v. Subaru on winter roads
I have a 2010 A4 Quattro (no sport diff), my wife has a 2011 Subaru Impreza. If I go around a corner on a slushy road in my Audi and the car is sliding into oversteer, the oversteer suddenly stops and the car then travels in a straight line; the skid has been corrected. I'm assuming this is the traction control system, correct?
So does anybody happen to know what system Subaru uses and how it will handle similar skids?
So does anybody happen to know what system Subaru uses and how it will handle similar skids?
#2
I have a 2010 A4 Quattro (no sport diff), ..
If I go around a corner on a slushy road in my Audi and the car is sliding into oversteer, the oversteer suddenly stops and the car then travels in a straight line; the skid has been corrected. I'm assuming this is the traction control system, correct?
If I go around a corner on a slushy road in my Audi and the car is sliding into oversteer, the oversteer suddenly stops and the car then travels in a straight line; the skid has been corrected. I'm assuming this is the traction control system, correct?
#3
AudiWorld Member
Join Date: Jun 2010
Location: Central NJ
Posts: 123
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Is the Impreza auto or manual?
I've never driven a Subaru with traction control (and my wife hasn't had her Q5 in snow yet), but in a sliding situation both of Subaru's AWD systems react more quickly when you keep your foot on the accelerator. My wife was skidding going downhill in her automatic Outback and regained traction by gently staying on the gas.
From Subaru.com:
My advice is to find a big empty parking lot in the snow to see how both cars react in a sliding situation. You don't even have to be going that fast to force the car into a slide and get a feel for the AWD.
-Dennis
I've never driven a Subaru with traction control (and my wife hasn't had her Q5 in snow yet), but in a sliding situation both of Subaru's AWD systems react more quickly when you keep your foot on the accelerator. My wife was skidding going downhill in her automatic Outback and regained traction by gently staying on the gas.
From Subaru.com:
Continuous All-Wheel Drive
Models equipped with 5-speed manual transmissions utilize a viscous-type locking center differential with torque distribution normally configured at a 50/50-split front-to-rear. If wheel speed differs between front and rear axles, the system helps distribute power to the wheels with the most traction.
Active All-Wheel Drive
Models equipped with 4-speed automatic transmission utilize an electronically controlled variable transfer clutch to distribute power where traction is needed. Sensors monitor parameters such as wheel slippage, throttle position and braking to help determine torque distribution and direct it to the wheels with optimum traction.
Models equipped with 5-speed manual transmissions utilize a viscous-type locking center differential with torque distribution normally configured at a 50/50-split front-to-rear. If wheel speed differs between front and rear axles, the system helps distribute power to the wheels with the most traction.
Active All-Wheel Drive
Models equipped with 4-speed automatic transmission utilize an electronically controlled variable transfer clutch to distribute power where traction is needed. Sensors monitor parameters such as wheel slippage, throttle position and braking to help determine torque distribution and direct it to the wheels with optimum traction.
-Dennis
#5
AudiWorld Member
Thread Starter
Before buying the QA4, I owned a Saab 9-2x manual (which is mechanically the same as a 2005 WRX). AWD, no traction control. What worked best in a cornering skid with that car was taking my foot off the gas, declutching, and waiting a fraction of a sec for the skid to stop, then going into gear and applying the gas gently. But it had no traction control. The A4 is far superior in the snow due to traction control.
#6
AudiWorld Member
Join Date: Jun 2010
Location: Central NJ
Posts: 123
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I presume the new Impreza will also be better due to VDC and TCS.
Vehicle Dynamics Control (VDC)
VDC electronic stability control utilizes sensors which constantly monitor wheel speed, steering angle, brake pressure, vehicle yaw rate and lateral g-forces. If VDC detects a difference between the driver's intended path and the one the vehicle is actually taking, VDC applies braking power and/or reduces engine torque to help correct vehicle path.
Traction Control System (TCS)
VDC also incorporates an all-wheel, all-speed traction control system which, when sensing a loss of traction, applies braking force and reduces engine torque to the slipping wheel or wheels as necessary to maintain vehicle motion.
In my Forester XT without traction control, I've never had any issues with skidding except when I've braked too hard at a stop. The Nokian WRG2's I now run on the Forester and Q5 help with braking.
-Dennis
Vehicle Dynamics Control (VDC)
VDC electronic stability control utilizes sensors which constantly monitor wheel speed, steering angle, brake pressure, vehicle yaw rate and lateral g-forces. If VDC detects a difference between the driver's intended path and the one the vehicle is actually taking, VDC applies braking power and/or reduces engine torque to help correct vehicle path.
Traction Control System (TCS)
VDC also incorporates an all-wheel, all-speed traction control system which, when sensing a loss of traction, applies braking force and reduces engine torque to the slipping wheel or wheels as necessary to maintain vehicle motion.
In my Forester XT without traction control, I've never had any issues with skidding except when I've braked too hard at a stop. The Nokian WRG2's I now run on the Forester and Q5 help with braking.
-Dennis
#7
AudiWorld Member
Join Date: Aug 2009
Location: California
Posts: 559
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
The B8 A4 ESP is exceptional. At a recent track day at Infineon Raceway, it was raining pretty heavily in the morning and I had the opportunity to swap some seat time in a Porsche 996 Turbo. The Porsche owner felt (as did I) that the Audi had better grip than the Porsche AWD system. The transfer of power was certainly smoother in the Audi than the Porsche. I chalk it up to electronics/ESP programming. I was reviewing some video footage the other day and it was funny (for me not them) to watch a BMW M Coupe fishtailing all the way from T1 to T4. At least he managed to keep it on the track which is more than I can say for at least 6 people that morning. The ESP complements the quattro system really well and can be felt distributing power smoothly.
Be careful testing in a parking lot. Things can be alot of fun on snow until you dig through it and hit ice...whole different ball game. Ice, natures humbler.
Be careful testing in a parking lot. Things can be alot of fun on snow until you dig through it and hit ice...whole different ball game. Ice, natures humbler.
Trending Topics
#8
AudiWorld Senior Member
#9
AudiWorld Senior Member
Join Date: Nov 2009
Location: Montreal, Que. (Canada)
Posts: 1,504
Likes: 0
Received 3 Likes
on
3 Posts
So, yes, ice is nature's humbler .
#10
AudiWorld Member
My '09 Forester XT Ltd. (with TCS and VDC) drives almost identically to my A4 in the snow; really the only difference is the ground clearance in the Subaru (good) and resultant higher center of gravity (not so good). The Audi feels a little more stable and connected to the road, while the Subaru will plow through deeper stuff; otherwise I find the feel to be quite similar.
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
RTinNYC(again)
TT (Mk1) Discussion
32
02-07-2003 11:40 PM