off topic but need buying advice for third car
 

Car #1: 04 allroad
Car #2: 03 Honda Odyssey
Car #3: ?

If they were similarly priced, would you rather have a 2004 VW R32 w/35000mi or a 2002 Boxster (and not one loaded with extras) with 48000mi but a brand new engine?

Silver VW might still carry kids, golf clubs. Porsche is a beautiful red convertible.

VW has awd and stability control. Porsche is a beautiful red convertible.

....
 

VW is reasonably practical and the other is a beautiful red convertible....there's your answer...how practical do you need to be...if the word even enters the equation then the beautiful red convertible will have to wait:)