AudiWorld Forums

AudiWorld Forums (https://www.audiworld.com/forums/)
-   Brakes Discussion (https://www.audiworld.com/forums/brakes-discussion-71/)
-   -   Q5 BRAKES. TRUE OR FALSE. (https://www.audiworld.com/forums/brakes-discussion-71/q5-brakes-true-false-2941162/)

TitoPogi 01-18-2018 01:59 AM

Q5 BRAKES. TRUE OR FALSE.
 
So the dealership advised me that it’s time for some front brake pads and rotors. Is it true that the rotors are a different material so they can not be resurfaced and they must be replaced? This is the first I have heard of brake rotors needing to be replaced instead of resurfaced. Is the service writer just trying to make a extra few bucks off of me or is he telling the truth.

uberwgn 01-18-2018 03:33 AM

Do you know how many miles the vehicle has traveled since last brake service, Tito?

Not many re-surface these rotors. They're a throw-away item. the permissible wear limit is minimal before it's out of spec.

Stevereddy 01-18-2018 03:45 AM

Sad but true. Not many manufacturers making Rotors that can be turned. It’s all about fuel economy standards and initial cost to manufacturer

TitoPogi 01-18-2018 06:06 PM


Originally Posted by uberwgn (Post 25097897)
Do you know how many miles the vehicle has traveled since last brake service, Tito?The car only has 53,000 miles. This would be its first brake job.


Originally Posted by uberwgn (Post 25097897)
Not many re-surface these rotors. They're a throw-away item. the permissible wear limit is minimal before it's out of spec.

The dealer was saying the rotors are semi carbon or semi something that’s why they can’t cut the rotor.

TitoPogi 01-18-2018 06:06 PM


Originally Posted by uberwgn (Post 25097897)
Do you know how many miles the vehicle has traveled since last brake service, Tito?


Originally Posted by uberwgn (Post 25097897)
Not many re-surface these rotors. They're a throw-away item. the permissible wear limit is minimal before it's out of spec.


Car has 53,000 miles. This would be its first brake job.
The dealer was saying the rotors are semi carbon or semi something that’s why they can’t cut the rotor.

2014Q5 05-25-2018 08:36 AM

It's time for new front brake pads and rotors. Any other brands you recommend other than OEM?

Freakydude 03-13-2019 05:15 PM


Originally Posted by 2014Q5 (Post 25157399)
It's time for new front brake pads and rotors. Any other brands you recommend other than OEM?

first time here but in answer to the question above google Max Advanced Brakes, Richmond Hill Canada. I just got my set of drilled rotors and pads for a tad over $200 delivered. I thought hey even if they are junk I will get through winter and can put new brakes on in the summer at that price.
Rotors are bang on spec for size from Audi and actually I think these are better than the zimmerman I currently have on. The ceramic pads I got came with new wear sensors so all I have to buy is the hardware. They look no different to the akebono ones I have.
Again though they are bang on spec for size.
and by the way, I am a regular guy and have no connection to max brakes. I will update on performance in the future and I use my Q5 in my job as a sales guy, I do about 4,000 km per month so it won't take long for them to show any rotor warps or pad issues.

J. Patterson 03-13-2019 06:22 PM

I just put a set of Centric pads and rotors on a friends Q5. Easy enough job. It IS true that rotors might be approaching minimum thickness at 50000 miles but measuring them is the only way to know. I typically change rotors every other pad change on my Audis. That statement about the rotors being of a material that cannot be turned is unfortunately false. They were turned in manufacturing. Dealers don’t turn them though. There is very little extra thickness to work with. Go to TireRack.com and price out your pads and rotors to get a feel for what they cost. Whoever does the work WILL need VAG com (VCDS) or similar to retract the electric parking brake. I have VCDS but I used Carista and my iPhone to retract the parking brakes on my friends Q5. Worked like a charm. Carista is inexpensive. Nice to have when traveling too in case you get a CEL while away from home.

StopSign 03-17-2019 03:58 PM

I did Akebono ceramic pads (EUR1322) with new Zimmermann rotors a couple months ago. Wonderful feel, and the cost is surprisingly low. I think the rotors were $75 each (via Prime) and the pads around $80 (also Amazon). Changing them was easy, but you could find anyone to do it for you for less than the dealer. I just added the Akebono rears (EUR1018) to cut out the dust.

Just an FYI.

ETA: didn't answer your question. Yes, they can be turned. No, Audi nor most Euro specialists will do it. The cost to replace is cheap enough that it wouldn't be worth paying for, IMO.

Freakydude 12-16-2021 03:09 PM


Originally Posted by Freakydude (Post 25289065)
first time here but in answer to the question above google Max Advanced Brakes, Richmond Hill Canada. I just got my set of drilled rotors and pads for a tad over $200 delivered. I thought hey even if they are junk I will get through winter and can put new brakes on in the summer at that price.
Rotors are bang on spec for size from Audi and actually I think these are better than the zimmerman I currently have on. The ceramic pads I got came with new wear sensors so all I have to buy is the hardware. They look no different to the akebono ones I have.
Again though they are bang on spec for size.
and by the way, I am a regular guy and have no connection to max brakes. I will update on performance in the future and I use my Q5 in my job as a sales guy, I do about 4,000 km per month so it won't take long for them to show any rotor warps or pad issues.

2 years since this last post and the max advance brakes are still going strong. I probably have at least another 2 years as it looks like they haven't worn much. No issues with the rotors either. None and I paid just under 400 for the whole kit which is about 1/3 the cost of Zimmerman and akebono here in Canada


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 08:41 PM.


© 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands