I don’t understand why people keep saying that I should wear a seatbelt. I’ve been driving without a seatbelt for 25 years without issue. I’m not starting on that now!

/sarcasm

Seriously, though. The consensus is to run separate winter and summer setups for lots of good reasons. But if you aren’t willing to accept that recommendation from the group on its merits, what makes you think that an all-season tire recommendation would better? It sounds like you’re just looking for confirmation of a decision you’ve already made.

Try doing research on Tire Rack. The professional reviews are good, and user ratings are pretty good too. Certainly the sample size of feedback on Tire Rack is bigger and better than what you’ll get from a 2nd gen Q7 specific sub-forum on a niche Audi enthusiast site...