Originally Posted by snagitseven
One defective part out of the thousands in the car does not necessarily make a lemon. Even a new, ordered car can have an issue or two. If you are happy with your choice and satisfied with the price, I wouldn't be too concerned over a replaced starter. If not, then pass and find another one but realize any new car can have a problem or two after delivery. That's what a warranty is for.
Well said. New cars unfortunately have problems. That one developed one before you even took it but it could have just as easily been one week after you got it. It is exactly the point of warranties.
But you don't have to take that car but just know you may not get the same deal else where. If you are fine with that then do what you feel most comfortable with.