spaniardone

help me make up my mind guys.. I like the Carrera 4S and the S5, I can't afford both.. what would you suggest based on your expertise.

AudiSTL

Are you going with a fully loaded Carrera as well? If so, I'd go with the Porsche. If it's a zero-optioned Carrera, then I'd go with the S5.

Tifosi

Daily driver ? family and kids/ages ? buying or leasing ?

Q

As the owner of a C4S, I'd have to say the Porsche

nvofevery1

Tough decision. Agree with the above about the purpose of the car. If it's just you and you need a daily driver, then the S5. If you have a family and an SUV (or the like), the C4S is an extraordinary second/weekend car.

rugg1132

You do realize that one costs nearly twice as much as the other right?

elf_cruiser

if you're taller than 6'2" - get the S5...

Q

Drove it everyday, sometimes even in the winter.

A8Liter

Get the S5, and with the extra money you saved over the Porsche you can get a Lotus Exige for the weekend!

um_terps

The C4S has plenty of headroom. The car is quite roomy.

That said, the S5 is more practical for everyday use if you need to load 4 adults.

It would depend on what you need it for.

Given a choice, I would always pick my C4 to drive, but the A5 is quite good as well.

2 different driving experiences. Go drive them, and then go with what works better for you.