Mechanic "Beating up" My Car on Test Drive
The following users liked this post:
DCB1951 (01-18-2020)
#52
Tempest in the Teapot
I don't think OP thinks this is a 'big deal' in the sense that he's going to demand a new car or have them replace the engine and transmission. He's rightfully annoyed that the mechanic did this, which basically was a joyride. As I've mentioned before, how would you feel if a valet did this to your car? Or what if it was a mechanic when your car was in for an oil change? Maybe you wouldn't care, but personally I would be very annoyed by this unprofessional behavior.
I guess what I don't get from the people defending this, do you feel this is appropriate behavior? How do you know this mechanic isn't doing this to every high performance vehicle? I think OPs reaction and resolution was completely justified.
I guess what I don't get from the people defending this, do you feel this is appropriate behavior? How do you know this mechanic isn't doing this to every high performance vehicle? I think OPs reaction and resolution was completely justified.
The following users liked this post:
Mister Bally (01-17-2020)
#53
Club AutoUnion
And the Tesla dealer (assuming it was a new vehicle) never asked for his drivers license & insurance card - and let him “test drive” it alone? Are Tesla dealers that desperate to sell cars? And, if it was a private seller, who would be stupid enough to let a total stranger “test drive” their car?
To quote Forrest Gump, “Stupid is as Stupid does.”
— John
#54
AudiWorld Member
Thread Starter
I simply pointed out that their staff should be more respectful to the client's property regardless of its cost and, most importantly, accelerating on the local street, most likely, tripling it's speed limit, is beyond stupid.
I wonder how would you feel if your child would be crossing/playing on that street when someone like him was on it? Would it "offend your sensibilities"?
Now, thanks to the dashboard camera, that boy racer will have some time to think about what he did.
Last edited by vexige; 01-17-2020 at 10:33 AM.
#55
AudiWorld Super User
And the Tesla dealer (assuming it was a new vehicle) never asked for his drivers license & insurance card - and let him “test drive” it alone? Are Tesla dealers that desperate to sell cars? And, if it was a private seller, who would be stupid enough to let a total stranger “test drive” their car?
To quote Forrest Gump, “Stupid is as Stupid does.”
— John
To quote Forrest Gump, “Stupid is as Stupid does.”
— John
#56
Club AutoUnion
The following users liked this post:
Mister Bally (01-17-2020)
#57
I don't think OP thinks this is a 'big deal' in the sense that he's going to demand a new car or have them replace the engine and transmission. He's rightfully annoyed that the mechanic did this, which basically was a joyride. As I've mentioned before, how would you feel if a valet did this to your car? Or what if it was a mechanic when your car was in for an oil change? Maybe you wouldn't care, but personally I would be very annoyed by this unprofessional behavior. I guess what I don't get from the people defending this, do you feel this is appropriate behavior? How do you know this mechanic isn't doing this to every high performance vehicle? I think OPs reaction and resolution was completely justified.
Would not categorize particular blog this as a love of complaining, but more along the lines of what are reasonable expectations when dropping off cars for service. Most would not want to drop off where miscreants are permitted to screw off, and will opt to patronize another dealership that respects its customers.
#58
To chime in here, I 100% agree with the OP. He paid for his car and it’s his property. He may choose to launch it into space every morning if he pleases - it’s his car. NO ONE - not even a service technician - has the right to abuse his property, without his explicit consent. No matter what that car is capable of. I cannot understand how some people here are arguing that it’s ok to drive someone else’s car hard and beat up on it - because the car was built for that. If anyone did that to my car, I would absolutely be upset about it. It’s for no one to decide, but him!
#59
To chime in here, I 100% agree with the OP. He paid for his car and it’s his property. He may choose to launch it into space every morning if he pleases - it’s his car. NO ONE - not even a service technician - has the right to abuse his property, without his explicit consent. No matter what that car is capable of. I cannot understand how some people here are arguing that it’s ok to drive someone else’s car hard and beat up on it - because the car was built for that. If anyone did that to my car, I would absolutely be upset about it. It’s for no one to decide, but him!
So taking the car to red line is abuse b/c I say so. Or do I say the opposite? The important thing is what I say not whether some physical change took place.
#60
From my perspective there are two issues here:
The second item hasn't been addressed yet however. Fortunately nothing went wrong such as an accident where property, a person or pet were harmed. What if the technician crashed? Now certainly the dealership would have repaired any damage. HOWEVER, we all know that a damaged and repaired vehicle looses value due to the crash and rarely is ever the same after the repair. I seriously doubt the dealership would have replaced the entire vehicle or compensated the owner had the technician crashed or damaged the car. Even minor fender benders can result in permanent issues with a car. I've experienced this personally on several vehicles over the years. Body parts don't line up, paint isn't quite matched, rattles develop, etc, etc, etc. The owner ends bearing the long term costs and that isn't right.
- Personal property and the choice of what happens to it
- Financial impact had something gone wrong resulting in damage to the vehicle
The second item hasn't been addressed yet however. Fortunately nothing went wrong such as an accident where property, a person or pet were harmed. What if the technician crashed? Now certainly the dealership would have repaired any damage. HOWEVER, we all know that a damaged and repaired vehicle looses value due to the crash and rarely is ever the same after the repair. I seriously doubt the dealership would have replaced the entire vehicle or compensated the owner had the technician crashed or damaged the car. Even minor fender benders can result in permanent issues with a car. I've experienced this personally on several vehicles over the years. Body parts don't line up, paint isn't quite matched, rattles develop, etc, etc, etc. The owner ends bearing the long term costs and that isn't right.