Voice navigation is disgraceful
#21
AudiWorld Member
Android Auto / Google Voice works fantastically. Dumps me right into either Waze or Google Maps, depending on preference. Android auto is how car integration is meant to be done.
#22
AudiWorld Senior Member
Apple Maps looks better but I can careless when you take the scenic route or just direct me the wrong place all together.
Another benefit of Google Assistant comes with there other products, I have multiple google homes and use them to control my Smart Home. Over time Google Assistant learns your voice and gets better at understanding you.
#23
AudiWorld Super User
I have an iPhone and Apple Maps and Siri is no where near the functionality of Google Assistant and Google Maps. I never use Siri. Every virtual assistant is better then Siri. Google Assistant, Alexa and even Cortana (especially now that you can use Alexa with Cortana).
Apple Maps looks better but I can careless when you take the scenic route or just direct me the wrong place all together.
Another benefit of Google Assistant comes with there other products, I have multiple google homes and use them to control my Smart Home. Over time Google Assistant learns your voice and gets better at understanding you.
Apple Maps looks better but I can careless when you take the scenic route or just direct me the wrong place all together.
Another benefit of Google Assistant comes with there other products, I have multiple google homes and use them to control my Smart Home. Over time Google Assistant learns your voice and gets better at understanding you.
I agree, though, Siri is the worst digital assistant out of the major ones. It's been for a long time. Carplay also consistently fares worst when it comes to being distracting and it's primarily due to Siri.
#24
AudiWorld Super User
I agree. Our 18 SB sux too, compared to my BMW540
I have 17k miles on my '18 SB and have tried very hard to use the voice commands for the Nav system. I give up .It simply doesn't work worth a tinker's damn. I have spoken to the dealer several times and they give me their wry smile and a pat on the head but I can never get it to work properly. When I use it, it reminds me of a comedy sketch where the driver goes nuts because everything that I ask for is misunderstood to the extreme. I have moved on to using CarPlay and asking Siri for directions. That works but I should need a work around for the car's Nav system.
I like the SB for different reasons but I like the 540 too.
#25
AudiWorld Super User
Thanks for the help but you fail the main point...
What specific commands are you using that aren't working? Are you doing it while stationary or while driving on potentially a noisy road? Also, are you in your car by yourself or is somebody with you and are they talking? Generally, I don't have issues with the Audi voice recognition. I don't actually use it all that often as most of the time I plan my destinations in advance and just send them to the car from my phone. I occasionally use the Google search command to navigate to an unplanned destination and the success rate is probably around 98%. Other than Google search, don't try to use POI commands with the MMI. The internal database is severely outdated and it's not very straight forward to navigate to a place by name unless you use the Google search command. If I have somebody in the car, I don't even try to use voice commands unless they are quiet. Most voice systems get confused if somebody else is talking at the same time. Google is the first who claims their latest technology can pick a single person out of a crowed, but I haven't tried it yet.
Apple didn't develop Siri. They acquired a company. Sure they added to it and improved it over time, but as mentioned above, more complex voice interactions such as trying to text are often futile. I have yet to use a system that understands me every time. It just doesn't exist. Short interactions generally work ok. Directions work ok, unless the name of the street sounds foreign or the business name sounds foreign. Google does a better job at guessing based on its database, but honestly I find myself repeating the commands often and then have to resort to typing because neither Siri nor Google gets what I'm looking for.
I've also noticed that some people talk like a machine when they use voice commands, which often doesn't work. Speak naturally and at the same volume that you speak to a person who isn't deaf. Raising the volume of your voice or even yelling generally doesn't work. If your car interior is noisy then the background noise will interfere. I'm generally impressed how well it works despite road noise in most cars I've driven, but for example in the R8 it's useless to try using voice command while driving. The engine and exhaust are too loud, but in most other Audi's it works pretty well unless there is a lot of road noise. Some road surfaces in the USA generate a lot of noise. Not sure where you live, but I used to travel to Texas a lot for example and the way they surfaces their highways generates a lot of noise while driving. Here in CA they use normal asphalt and especially all the roads that have been resurfaced recently are very quiet now. The older concrete roads are much louder.
Apple didn't develop Siri. They acquired a company. Sure they added to it and improved it over time, but as mentioned above, more complex voice interactions such as trying to text are often futile. I have yet to use a system that understands me every time. It just doesn't exist. Short interactions generally work ok. Directions work ok, unless the name of the street sounds foreign or the business name sounds foreign. Google does a better job at guessing based on its database, but honestly I find myself repeating the commands often and then have to resort to typing because neither Siri nor Google gets what I'm looking for.
I've also noticed that some people talk like a machine when they use voice commands, which often doesn't work. Speak naturally and at the same volume that you speak to a person who isn't deaf. Raising the volume of your voice or even yelling generally doesn't work. If your car interior is noisy then the background noise will interfere. I'm generally impressed how well it works despite road noise in most cars I've driven, but for example in the R8 it's useless to try using voice command while driving. The engine and exhaust are too loud, but in most other Audi's it works pretty well unless there is a lot of road noise. Some road surfaces in the USA generate a lot of noise. Not sure where you live, but I used to travel to Texas a lot for example and the way they surfaces their highways generates a lot of noise while driving. Here in CA they use normal asphalt and especially all the roads that have been resurfaced recently are very quiet now. The older concrete roads are much louder.
#26
AudiWorld Member
#27
AudiWorld Senior Member
Just don't get the southern upgrade -
#29
AudiWorld Member
My biggest gripe with it is that it doesn't pronounce street names like a $100 Garmin handheld GPS unit from 15 years ago. I mean really, is it too much to ask in the year 2018 in a 60k+ car?
Last edited by Stankia; 09-21-2018 at 11:16 PM.
#30
AudiWorld Super User
Is the location in your profile (Lithuania) correct? If so, that's a matter of how well your country has been digitized by HERE who is providing the map data. Street names are pronounced here in the USA as part of the turn-by-turn announcements.