Broker

I'm having my timing belt done in the next week or two.

Question: If you had a choice between having the service performed by the dealer or by an independent...how much of a cost savings would there need to be for you to choose the independent?

Ben's e//S2

if the independant is an audi/vw guy, then i'd go with them. regardless of the size of the savings, there will be a savings no matter what. and timing belt is a pretty straight forward job for a mechanic.

Pizzicato

you can save upwards of $500 by seeking independant garage

Broker

Thanks, but doesn't answer the question.

Pizzicato

Duhhhhhhhh !!....Sounds like 500 good reasons to me !!

Broker

At what point would you see the value in going to the dealer?

Perhaps for some people the dealer would have to be cheaper.

Pizzicato

Is there still a warranty on the car? will independant garage furnish a car loaner?,Do you trust your Audi Dealer? Different hourly wages?,its a question of reaching a certain comfort level

Broker

No warranty. No loaner (no matter which you choose). Yes, I trust the Audi Dealer. Indep. comes recommended.


I honestly didn't think the question was this difficult.

Maybe worded this way...

What premium (if any) would wou be willing to pay for the piece of mind of having your car repaired by the dealer vs. an independent shop?

Given the following assumptions:
1) neither the dealer nor the independent will give you a loaner.
2) you have had good reliable fair service from the dealer in the past
3) the car has no warranty.
4) the independent comes recommended by people you trust.


Hopefully that is clear.

Pizzicato

wether it be $10 or $100,better in your pocket than in the dealers coffers !!

Liam in Montreal

I don't have ANYTHING done at a dealer. lots of competent and trustworthy mechanics out there..